Free MIDI Editors Compared: MuseScore vs Signal vs LMMS

By Cihad Turhan · · 5 min read

A marble bouncing between paddles in Marble Music after importing a cleaned-up MIDI file

For cleaning up a MIDI file before you import it into a video app, three free editors cover almost every need: MuseScore Studio if you think in sheet music, Signal if you want a quick piano-roll editor in your browser, and LMMS if you want a full music-production workspace. All three are free and open source.

Which one is "best" depends on how you like to see notes and how much you plan to do. This comparison focuses on the edits creators actually make: deleting a drum track, setting the tempo, trimming a silent intro and keeping only the melody.

Two ways to see the same notes

Before comparing tools, it helps to know the two views MIDI editors use:

  • Notation (sheet music): notes on a staff, with clefs, bars and rests. Familiar if you read music, and great for spotting wrong notes in a melody.
  • Piano roll: a grid where each note is a horizontal bar. Higher bars are higher notes, longer bars last longer. No music reading needed, and great for dragging, deleting and trimming.

MuseScore is notation-first. Signal and LMMS are piano-roll-first.

The comparison at a glance

MuseScore Studio Signal LMMS
Main view Sheet music Piano roll Piano roll plus song and beat editors
Runs on Windows, macOS, Linux Web browser (can be installed as an app) Windows, macOS, Linux
Install needed Yes No Yes
Opens MIDI Yes Yes Yes (import)
Saves MIDI Yes, File → Export Yes, it's a MIDI editor Exports audio; check its menus for MIDI options
Learning curve Moderate Low Higher
Best for Fixing melodies, typing in a public-domain score Fast cleanup Producing original tracks

Sources: MuseScore handbook on export, Signal, and LMMS on Wikipedia.

MuseScore Studio: for people who read music

MuseScore Studio opens a MIDI file as a score. That's ideal when the problem is musical: a wrong note in the melody, a doubled octave, or a piece you'd rather type in yourself from a public-domain score on IMSLP.

Strengths:

  • You see the melody as written music, so mistakes jump out.
  • Typing a melody by hand produces a clean, single-track MIDI you made yourself.
  • MIDI export includes an option to expand repeats, so repeated sections play in full.

Watch out for: imported MIDI files can look messy as notation, with odd rests and ties, because MIDI stores timing, not how a score should be printed. The music plays correctly even if it looks cluttered.

Signal: for fast, no-install cleanup

Signal is an open-source MIDI editor that runs in the browser, with a multi-track piano roll. Open the file, delete what you don't need, save. It's the quickest path for the most common fixes.

Strengths:

  • Nothing to install; it works on any computer with a modern browser.
  • Each track is easy to mute or remove, so you can find the melody by listening.
  • The piano roll makes trimming the start, the most common fix for video clips, a simple drag.

Watch out for: it's a focused MIDI editor, not a notation program, so it won't help you read the music as a score.

LMMS: for making your own music

LMMS is a free, open-source music production app with a piano roll, a beat and bassline editor, and a song editor. It can import MIDI files and export finished audio.

Strengths:

  • A full workspace for composing original music, which sidesteps rights questions entirely.
  • Built-in instruments and SoundFont support for hearing your parts properly.

Watch out for: it's more than you need for a quick MIDI fix, and the extra panels take time to learn. If you only want to delete a drum track, start with Signal or MuseScore.

Which one should you pick?

  • "I read sheet music." MuseScore Studio.
  • "I just need to delete a track and trim the start." Signal.
  • "I want to compose my own music for videos." LMMS.

Save a copy of the full file before you strip it down, because multi-track files are useful as they are elsewhere. RingLoop turns each MIDI track into its own ring in its level editor and lets you adjust the mix per ring or split dense parts across rings, so the original file and your cleaned melody can each feed a different video.

Try one edit today

Whichever editor you pick, the cleanup checklist for a marble video is the same: one clear melody track, no drums, the right tempo, and the first note at the very start.

  1. Download a public-domain file from /midis, for example Swan Lake, and check the license of any file you didn't make.
  2. Open it in Signal or MuseScore Studio, mute each track in turn to find the melody, and delete the rest.
  3. Drag the first note to the start of bar one so the clip opens on a bounce, then save or export as .mid.
  4. Import both versions into Marble Music (formerly Beat Bounce) in the level editor and play them side by side. The cleaned file usually gives one clean bounce per melody note instead of a cluster.

Then edit the level and render. For posting, see the bouncing ball video tutorial.

Frequently asked questions

What is the easiest free MIDI editor?
For quick fixes like deleting a track or changing the tempo, Signal is the fastest to start because it runs in a web browser with nothing to install. If you read sheet music, MuseScore Studio will feel more natural.
Can I edit a MIDI file on my phone?
The three editors here are built for computers or the browser. For a quick edit, you can try Signal in a browser, but a laptop or desktop screen makes note editing much easier.

Get Marble Music (formerly Beat Bounce)

Free on iOS, Android and Steam. Turn songs and MIDI into bouncing-marble music videos and render them in 4K.

Download Marble Music on the App StoreGet Marble Music on Google PlayGet Marble Music on Steam

More apps from the developer