How to Pick a Song for a Marble Video: A 5-Point Scorecard

By Cihad Turhan · · 6 min read

A rainbow marble bouncing between paddles, landing on every note of the chosen song in Marble Music

To pick a song that works as a marble video, score it on five points: can people recognize it within three seconds, does it have one clear melody, is the note density readable as bounces, is its best section short enough for a clip, and how much rights risk does it carry. A song that scores well on all five gives your video a better chance than a trending track that fails two of them.

No song guarantees views, but you can check a song's fit before you spend time rendering. Below are the scorecard, three worked examples from the site's free MIDI files, and a routine for checking trends.

The 5-point scorecard

Give each point 0, 1 or 2. A total of 8 or more is a strong pick, 6 or 7 needs a fix first, and 5 or less is worth skipping.

Point Score 2 Score 1 Score 0
1. Recognition in 3 seconds Most people know the opening Known, but by feel rather than by name Only fans would know it
2. Clear melody One melody line on top Melody plus busy accompaniment Many tracks, melody buried
3. Readable density A few notes per second Busy passages you can trim around A constant blur
4. Best section length The best part fits in 10–30 seconds It needs some trimming The best part takes a minute to arrive
5. Rights risk Public-domain composition, MIDI license checked Public-domain piece, MIDI license unclear Copyrighted modern song

Point 5 counts double in practice: a modern song can score 8 on the other four points and still get your video muted or removed. More on that below.

How to measure points 2 and 3

No music theory needed. Open the MIDI in Marble Music (formerly Beat Bounce), import it, and play the level once while asking two questions.

  1. Can you hum along to the bounces? If you can follow the tune from the marble alone, the melody is clear. If you hear chords and fills but lose the tune, score it lower.
  2. Can your eye keep up? Count the bounces in a five-second stretch of the busiest part. If you lose count, viewers will too.

The number of tracks in a file is a fast warning sign. A two-track piano file usually has a melody hand and an accompaniment hand. A file with 15 or 20 tracks is an orchestral arrangement where every instrument adds bounces.

Three songs, scored

I counted the notes in each of these files from the MIDI page to score them.

Can-Can (Offenbach), orchestral file: 6/10

The Can_Can.mid file is instantly recognizable, and the gallop arrives right away. But it has 20 tracks and nearly 7,000 notes in 93 seconds, which averages over 70 notes per second.

  • Recognition 2, melody 0, density 0, section length 2, rights 2.
  • Fix: switch to the piano duet version, which has 4 tracks and about 20 notes per second, then edit the level to thin out the busiest bars. That lifts melody and density to 1 each, for an 8.

Moonlight Sonata, first movement (Beethoven): 7/10

The first movement file has two tracks and about three notes per second at a steady 44 beats per minute. That's beautifully readable, and the opening triplet pattern is widely known.

  • Recognition 2, melody 1 (the famous triplets are accompaniment, with a quieter melody on top), density 2, section length 0 (the file runs over six minutes, and the mood builds slowly), rights 2.
  • Fix: don't try to show the build. Clip the first 20 seconds as a calm loop, and you can score section length as 2, for a 9.

Morning Mood (Grieg), simplified: 9/10

The simplified Morning Mood runs 54 seconds with two tracks. Its density barely changes: 24 to 29 notes in each of its first four five-second windows. The melody, played by the flute in Grieg's original, is familiar even to people who couldn't name it.

  • Recognition 1, melody 2, density 2, section length 2, rights 2.
  • Use it as is. This is the kind of file to start with when you're new to the format.

Check what's trending, then decide

Trends tell you what people are listening to this week. They don't tell you whether a song will make a good marble video, so run every trending song through the same scorecard.

  • TikTok: TikTok's Creative Center has a trends section for songs. Use it to spot songs gaining traction, not as a list of things to cover.
  • Reels and Shorts: note which sounds keep coming back in your own feed over a week, and which of them are piano or instrumental pieces.
  • Look for classical crossovers. Every so often, a public-domain melody shows up in a trend, often through a film, a meme or a remix. When that happens, the original composition is a low-risk way to join in. Use your own MIDI of the original rather than the trending recording.

A trending modern song almost always scores 0 on point 5. You can still make a video with it, but covers of copyrighted songs carry copyright risk on every platform, so check each platform's music policy first.

Why public-domain classics are the safe base

Most trends fade quickly, while the pieces above have been well known for over a century. A channel built on public-domain classics can re-theme and repost the same songs for years without new rights questions, with trends as occasional extras.

A public-domain composition doesn't make every MIDI arrangement free to use, so check the license of any file you use, or export your own from a public-domain score.

A good song for a marble video often makes a good learning video too. If a public-domain piano piece scores well, you can also turn it into a "learn this on sheet music" clip in Note Bounce, our sister rhythm game. Its bouncing balls land on real sheet music and it imports MIDI, so one file gives you two kinds of post.

Score your next song

Pick three candidates, score each one in the table, and render only the winner. Keep a note of each song's score next to how long people watched it, and after a few posts you'll see which of the five points matters most for your audience. If you're new to rendering, the step-by-step TikTok tutorial covers the full flow, and you can get the app from the Marble Music home page.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use popular songs in my TikTok videos?
A cover of a copyrighted song, including a MIDI version, can still be flagged, muted or removed, because the composition itself is protected. Check each platform's music policy before posting, or choose a public-domain piece to avoid the question.
What tempo works best for bouncing ball videos?
Note density matters more than the BPM number. As a rough guide, a melody with a few notes per second shows every bounce clearly, while a file with dozens of notes per second turns into a blur unless you edit the level.

Get Marble Music (formerly Beat Bounce)

Free on iOS, Android and Steam. Turn songs and MIDI into bouncing-marble music videos and render them in 4K.

Download Marble Music on the App StoreGet Marble Music on Google PlayGet Marble Music on Steam

More apps from the developer